Advocating Against AI in Schools

Writing and Media on Artificial Intelligence and Education

Kelly’s has been active working as a public scholar, organizer, and activist to resist AI in public school classrooms and Big Tech in education. Follow the links below to read Kelly’s writing on AI and explore Kelly’s media appearances.

Kelly in the Media

Excellent coverage and photos of recent protests on Google’s AI policies affecting schools by Greg Pak.

“According to Clancy, students can still access Gemini on tablets and phones at school, which reverts to Google’s AI Chat.” Speaking with Mother Jones about these policies.

“This is a perfect time for us to figure out how we can wean ourselves off of Google so that we don’t have companies able to blackmail us in order to create a captive audience of students.” – Critiquing Google’s denying access to schools banning AI in conversation with the Gothamist.

“We have to go back to the drawing board on how we are teaching our kids to research.” – Discussing Google restricting access on schools that ban AI with the NYT

Discussing Teacher Use of AI with NBC Ohio

Discussing AI Lesson Plans with NBC New York

From the The Guardian: In October, Kelly Clancy’s son received an assignment in sixth grade at a middle school in Brooklyn, New York, to create a science experiment and then ask Google Gemini, an artificial intelligence chatbot, for feedback, she said. Clancy, who has three children in New York City public schools, told the teacher that the bot “is something that just teaches kids that they can have machines do the thinking for them”, instead of suggesting: “Let’s talk to your partners. What about the science experiment could you improve?”

Discussing the Moratorium on AI in NYC Schools with CBS

Speaking with the New York Times: “The fact that this policy exists at all is due to the enormous work of parents across the city who spoke out against the overreach of A.I. into their kids’ classroom,” Ms. Clancy said.

Addressing the NYC AI Moratorium on Newsnation

From Edweek: “But AI bans are still worth pursuing despite the potential challenges, argued Kelly Clancy, a New York City public school mom and the leader of Parents for AI Caution in Educational Spaces, a grassroots organization. ‘Saying AI is in everything, so you can’t ban it, so we shouldn’t try, is a lazy argument,’ Clancy said.”

From the Gothamist: “Clancy, the parent advocate who opposes AI, called the pilot programs a “gift” to the technology industry. There’s no way that that’s getting [students] ready for the future. It’s just a way to outsource labor to AI instead of the teachers. So we really believe these pilots need to get out of schools,” she said.

Writing on AI in Education

“Most importantly, AI ed tech fails at the one task it was designed for: educating our children. Students’ use of generative AI in 3K to 12 classrooms produces a net-negative impact on cognitive development, creativity, and critical thinking…While the DOE pretends this is about equity, the children and families who will be most harmed by the racial bias, privacy violations and environmental pollution are the city’s Black and brown students.” – “Opinion: Dems and GOP Agree, We Need an AI Moratorium,” written with New York City Council Member Alexa Avilés, published in City & State New York.

“Far from being a safeguard, AI-powered war is a galling amplification of the Armageddon-driven whims of men in power who believe that God is on their side – and AI has no moral compass to stop it.” – from The Fog of War is No Cover for Unethical AI, with Christine Zenner.

“The DOE pretends these are tools for equity, ignoring the fact that schools in wealthier, whiter areas invest in humans, not in technology. Urban Assembly schools are promising AI chatbot college counselors for their students, while wealthy schools employ humans to do this work. In wealthy areas, there are small class sizes and highly engaged teachers. For the rest of the city? Screens and teachers trained as tech support. True equity is making sure that every child in this city has the right to an excellent education: small classes, actual books, a culturally relevant curriculum based in problem-solving, friction, and relationship development.” – from Kelly’s written testimony to New York City Council, published by First Fish Chronicles.

“Change is possible everywhere: if a few of us can move the needle in NYC, imagine what’s possible in your area. Start by asking questions— what’s going on in your school? Is your teacher or principal an ally? What’s happening on the district level? Finding likeminded parents can be helpful, and often that starts by just bringing up topics at community meetings.” – from A Week Inside: New York City Parents Rise Up against AI in Schools, published by the Fairplay’s Screentime Action Network.